YouTube’s Controversial Redesign Returns: Users Criticize New Layout

Highlights

• YouTube reintroduces controversial redesign, shifting video details to the side
• Initial user feedback on the redesign remains largely negative
• YouTube states the changes are part of an “experiment” with no clear end date
• The redesign may indicate YouTube is gathering more data and user feedback

YouTube seems to be reverting to a controversial redesign of its site, despite rampant negativity when the platform originally tested the new look earlier this year.

In mid-April, Google started testing a redesign that shifted the video title, description, and comments to the side of the screen.

In their place were video recommendations, just to the side of the video playing, with larger thumbnails and titles.

Most who saw it hated it.

Although the redesign did not appear for everyone, YouTube later scrapped the changes in the weeks that followed, as the criticism was all negative.

Criticism of New Design

But the terrible YouTube redesign has made a comeback.

A number of users have been reporting seeing the new look appear over the last few days, although it doesn’t appear to be a general rollout yet.

This seems like another round of testing.

The reemergence of this facelift begs the question of YouTube’s intentions.

It’s not sure whether this new layout will be the default experience, but with YouTube testing it over and over, it means they are collecting more data and feedback.

User Feedback

Some users have received responses to YouTube tweets suggesting that the change is only an “experiment.”

But these seem to be generic responses rather than ones specific to the situation. This might be an experiment, but there is no word on what YouTube is trying to achieve by the new design.

One response from YouTube confirmed that most trials “only last a few weeks,” although it is unclear if that is the case for this ongoing makeover test.

Overall, it is unclear what the future of this controversial design is, with YouTube likely weighing user feedback against their own statistics and goals.

FAQs

What changes does the YouTube redesign introduce?

The redesign moves the video title, description, and comments to the side of the screen, replacing them with larger video recommendations beside the playing video.

Why is the YouTube redesign controversial?

Users have expressed strong dislike for the new layout, criticizing it for being less intuitive and disrupting the traditional viewing experience.

Is the YouTube redesign permanent?

YouTube has labeled the redesign as an “experiment,” and it’s unclear if it will become the default layout. The company is currently gathering data and user feedback.

How are users reacting to the redesign’s return?

Many users have reported seeing the new layout again and have voiced their dissatisfaction, similar to the initial negative feedback earlier this year.

Also Read: YouTube Music Rolls Out Offline Listening for Desktop and Updates Android Share Sheet 

Also Read: YouTube Music Introduces Activity Feed and New Creator Content Disclosure Policy